You can show your support by sponsoring this page for $5. Home All-time Team Position Rating through 1944
  Your ad/message will appear in this space for one year.   Annual Index
  Thank you for your support!  
   
       
Cumulative Cumulative
Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate
    1 San Francisco Giants New York NL CL 184.534    91 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SP 99.729
    2 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL MR 141.394    92 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 2B 99.663
    3 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SS 134.760    93 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SS 99.648
    4 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL MR 131.250    94 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SP 99.595
    5 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL MR 129.158    95 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CF 98.214
    6 New York Yankees New York AL 1B 125.909    96 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SS 98.188
    7 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CF 125.409    97 Boston Red Sox Boston AL RF 97.852
    8 San Francisco Giants New York NL SS 124.349    98 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CL 97.787
    9 Boston Red Sox Boston AL MR 123.806    99 Minnesota Twins Washington AL C 97.746
   10 New York Yankees New York AL RF 121.530   100 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL LF 97.709
   11 San Francisco Giants New York NL RF 121.472   101 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL C 97.670
   12 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL RF 121.429   102 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SS 97.556
   13 San Francisco Giants New York NL C 120.009   103 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 2B 97.256
   14 New York Yankees New York AL C 119.312   104 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 1B 97.153
   15 San Francisco Giants New York NL 1B 118.720   105 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL MR 97.057
   16 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CL 118.480   106 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 1B 97.040
   17 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SP 117.794   107 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SP 96.944
   18 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CF 116.385   108 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CF 96.559
   19 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL C 116.060   109 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL RF 96.511
   20 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL C 115.829   110 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL MR 96.151
   21 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL RF 115.020   111 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CF 96.133
   22 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CL 115.018   112 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 2B 95.885
   23 New York Yankees New York AL 2B 114.802   113 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CF 95.508
   24 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SS 114.469   114 Boston Red Sox Boston AL C 95.450
   25 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 1B 114.323   115 Boston Red Sox Boston AL LF 95.078
   26 New York Yankees New York AL 3B 113.780   116 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 3B 95.025
   27 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 2B 113.536   117 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 1B 94.572
   28 New York Yankees New York AL SS 113.234   118 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 1B 94.230
   29 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL MR 113.228   119 Minnesota Twins Washington AL LF 94.180
   30 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 2B 113.041   120 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CF 94.169
   31 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 2B 112.917   121 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 3B 94.138
   32 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 3B 112.861   122 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL C 94.134
   33 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 1B 112.645   123 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SP 94.047
   34 New York Yankees New York AL LF 112.292   124 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL LF 93.634
   35 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SP 111.094   125 San Francisco Giants New York NL MR 93.583
   36 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CL 110.435   126 Minnesota Twins Washington AL RF 93.323
   37 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SP 110.374   127 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL MR 92.903
   38 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL MR 110.289   128 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 1B 92.728
   39 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CF 110.283   129 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SP 92.695
   40 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 1B 110.259   130 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SS 92.679
   41 San Francisco Giants New York NL 2B 110.057   131 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL C 92.201
   42 San Francisco Giants New York NL 3B 110.006   132 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CL 91.852
   43 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 2B 109.812   133 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL RF 91.663
   44 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 3B 109.799   134 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CF 91.564
   45 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SS 109.776   135 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SS 91.497
   46 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL LF 109.501   136 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL RF 90.486
   47 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL RF 109.443   137 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 2B 90.393
   48 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CF 109.222   138 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL C 90.218
   49 San Francisco Giants New York NL SP 109.146   139 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL RF 90.009
   50 New York Yankees New York AL CL 109.120   140 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 1B 89.907
   51 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL C 109.060   141 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL LF 89.659
   52 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL LF 109.009   142 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 3B 88.752
   53 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 3B 108.921   143 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL MR 88.643
   54 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CL 108.521   144 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 1B 88.369
   55 New York Yankees New York AL SP 108.108   145 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SS 88.141
   56 Minnesota Twins Washington AL MR 108.037   146 Atlanta Braves Boston NL C 88.043
   57 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 1B 107.941   147 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 3B 87.596
   58 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SS 107.780   148 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL C 87.481
   59 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL LF 107.131   149 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CF 87.257
   60 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL LF 106.574   150 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SS 86.910
   61 San Francisco Giants New York NL CF 105.946   151 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 1B 86.591
   62 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SP 105.790   152 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CL 86.338
   63 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CL 105.691   153 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SP 86.087
   64 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 2B 105.333   154 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CL 85.745
   65 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL LF 105.330   155 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CL 85.569
   66 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 3B 105.057   156 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SP 85.417
   67 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SP 105.028   157 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CF 85.271
   68 New York Yankees New York AL CF 104.908   158 Atlanta Braves Boston NL RF 85.212
   69 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL RF 104.796   159 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CL 85.056
   70 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 2B 104.607   160 Atlanta Braves Boston NL LF 83.825
   71 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 1B 103.409   161 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL C 83.724
   72 San Francisco Giants New York NL LF 103.331   162 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CL 83.408
   73 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL LF 102.853   163 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 2B 82.596
   74 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SP 102.446   164 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 3B 82.050
   75 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 3B 102.358   165 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 1B 81.740
   76 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL RF 102.335   166 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL MR 80.667
   77 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CF 102.198   167 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 2B 77.959
   78 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 2B 102.107   168 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SS 75.625
   79 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 3B 101.911   169 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 2B 74.725
   80 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL C 101.818   170 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL MR 74.636
   81 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CF 101.792   171 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL RF 74.540
   82 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL RF 101.763   172 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SS 73.058
   83 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL LF 101.645   173 Atlanta Braves Boston NL MR 69.035
   84 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 3B 101.003   174 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CL 68.713
   85 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL LF 100.967   175 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CL 67.547
   86 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SS 100.753   176 New York Yankees New York AL MR 50.051
   87 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL C 100.043
   88 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 3B 100.035
   89 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 3B 99.861
   90 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SP 99.801
Copyright © 2009-11 by Andre Lower
Sources:
All-Time Major League Handbook
Win Shares Digital Update
baseball-reference.com
ESPN Baseball Encyclopedia