You can show your support by sponsoring this page for $5. Home All-time Team Position Rating through 1919
  Your ad/message will appear in this space for one year.   Annual Index
  Thank you for your support!  
   
       
Cumulative Cumulative
Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate
    1 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL MR 260.690    91 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SP 99.081
    2 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL MR 205.364    92 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SP 98.656
    3 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL MR 185.050    93 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL RF 98.616
    4 San Francisco Giants New York NL CL 177.964    94 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SS 98.120
    5 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CF 154.850    95 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 3B 98.115
    6 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CL 154.713    96 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CF 97.728
    7 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL MR 149.744    97 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SP 97.243
    8 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 2B 140.154    98 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL C 96.942
    9 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL RF 139.332    99 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 1B 96.938
   10 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL RF 138.855   100 Minnesota Twins Washington AL MR 96.177
   11 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CL 133.736   101 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 2B 95.944
   12 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 2B 130.663   102 Minnesota Twins Washington AL C 95.897
   13 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 1B 129.953   103 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 3B 95.552
   14 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SS 129.630   104 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 1B 95.501
   15 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 1B 129.274   105 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL C 95.334
   16 San Francisco Giants New York NL C 126.264   106 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CL 95.222
   17 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 3B 125.063   107 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SS 94.951
   18 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL LF 123.884   108 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL LF 94.826
   19 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL C 122.582   109 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CL 94.717
   20 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CF 122.274   110 Atlanta Braves Boston NL C 94.692
   21 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL MR 121.905   111 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CL 94.354
   22 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CF 121.059   112 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL RF 93.757
   23 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SP 120.080   113 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL LF 93.556
   24 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SP 119.681   114 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 1B 93.521
   25 San Francisco Giants New York NL SS 119.177   115 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 3B 92.817
   26 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL RF 118.930   116 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 3B 92.726
   27 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 3B 118.206   117 New York Yankees New York AL SP 92.440
   28 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 3B 118.133   118 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 1B 92.322
   29 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL LF 117.679   119 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SS 92.291
   30 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 1B 116.867   120 New York Yankees New York AL C 92.027
   31 San Francisco Giants New York NL CF 116.540   121 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL C 90.957
   32 New York Yankees New York AL SS 116.286   122 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SP 90.886
   33 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SP 115.971   123 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CL 90.885
   34 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 2B 115.650   124 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL MR 90.090
   35 Boston Red Sox Boston AL C 114.641   125 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SP 90.077
   36 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 2B 114.338   126 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 1B 89.999
   37 San Francisco Giants New York NL 1B 114.162   127 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CF 89.862
   38 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SS 113.866   128 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 1B 89.506
   39 San Francisco Giants New York NL 2B 113.496   129 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 2B 89.442
   40 San Francisco Giants New York NL SP 112.274   130 Atlanta Braves Boston NL RF 88.955
   41 San Francisco Giants New York NL 3B 112.150   131 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 1B 88.894
   42 San Francisco Giants New York NL RF 111.812   132 New York Yankees New York AL 2B 88.490
   43 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CF 111.540   133 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 2B 87.731
   44 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SS 110.967   134 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 3B 87.186
   45 Boston Red Sox Boston AL RF 110.881   135 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL RF 87.158
   46 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 3B 110.388   136 New York Yankees New York AL LF 87.040
   47 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL C 109.602   137 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SS 86.939
   48 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL LF 109.395   138 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 1B 86.852
   49 Boston Red Sox Boston AL LF 109.307   139 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 2B 86.329
   50 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SS 109.129   140 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL C 85.497
   51 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL LF 108.661   141 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 2B 85.168
   52 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL LF 108.288   142 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 3B 85.161
   53 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 2B 108.240   143 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SP 84.994
   54 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CF 108.180   144 Atlanta Braves Boston NL LF 84.861
   55 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CL 107.363   145 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CF 84.795
   56 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL LF 107.223   146 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SS 84.655
   57 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL MR 107.134   147 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CF 84.641
   58 New York Yankees New York AL 3B 107.020   148 New York Yankees New York AL RF 84.448
   59 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CL 106.638   149 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SS 84.234
   60 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL C 106.573   150 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CL 83.774
   61 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SP 106.562   151 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL MR 83.458
   62 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL RF 106.494   152 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL LF 83.163
   63 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SS 106.368   153 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SS 83.125
   64 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SP 106.223   154 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CL 83.029
   65 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL C 105.773   155 Minnesota Twins Washington AL LF 81.283
   66 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL C 105.488   156 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CF 80.550
   67 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SS 105.331   157 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CF 80.067
   68 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL LF 104.829   158 New York Yankees New York AL CF 79.280
   69 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL RF 104.730   159 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 2B 79.220
   70 San Francisco Giants New York NL LF 104.461   160 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SS 78.149
   71 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 3B 103.888   161 Minnesota Twins Washington AL RF 78.096
   72 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SP 103.755   162 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CL 77.827
   73 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL LF 103.461   163 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 2B 74.221
   74 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL RF 103.387   164 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL C 73.968
   75 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CF 102.817   165 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 3B 73.812
   76 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 1B 101.623   166 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CL 72.971
   77 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 3B 101.327   167 New York Yankees New York AL CL 72.847
   78 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CF 100.824   168 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL RF 66.300
   79 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CL 100.772   169 San Francisco Giants New York NL MR 65.641
   80 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 1B 100.758   170 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CL 64.177
   81 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL RF 100.658   171 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL MR 60.872
   82 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CF 100.599   172 New York Yankees New York AL MR 56.002
   83 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL C 100.369   173 Boston Red Sox Boston AL MR 54.785
   84 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 3B 99.956   174 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL MR 46.887
   85 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 2B 99.948   175 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL MR 15.941
   86 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 1B 99.756   176 Atlanta Braves Boston NL MR 0.000
   87 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SP 99.727
   88 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 2B 99.500
   89 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SP 99.447
   90 New York Yankees New York AL 1B 99.368
Copyright © 2009-11 by Andre Lower
Sources:
All-Time Major League Handbook
Win Shares Digital Update
baseball-reference.com
ESPN Baseball Encyclopedia