You can show your support by sponsoring this page for $5. Home All-time Team Position Rating through 1910
  Your ad/message will appear in this space for one year.   Annual Index
  Thank you for your support!  
   
       
Cumulative Cumulative
Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate
    1 San Francisco Giants New York NL CL 198.943    81 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SP 101.609
    2 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CL 174.630    82 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL LF 100.378
    3 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 2B 163.230    83 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL RF 100.114
    4 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CL 157.998    84 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL C 100.079
    5 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CL 150.243    85 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL C 99.337
    6 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 2B 144.825    86 New York Yankees New York AL CF 98.352
    7 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL RF 143.156    87 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 3B 97.883
    8 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 1B 141.619    88 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SS 97.833
    9 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CF 141.410    89 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL RF 97.546
   10 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL RF 139.545    90 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SP 97.373
   11 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SS 134.828    91 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL LF 97.288
   12 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 1B 134.229    92 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 3B 97.072
   13 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL LF 131.249    93 Boston Red Sox Boston AL LF 96.955
   14 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 3B 126.775    94 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL LF 96.879
   15 San Francisco Giants New York NL C 126.433    95 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CL 96.764
   16 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CF 125.649    96 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 1B 96.643
   17 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 2B 125.404    97 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 3B 96.131
   18 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SP 123.378    98 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 1B 96.059
   19 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 3B 122.759    99 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CL 95.252
   20 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL C 122.633   100 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 1B 94.876
   21 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL LF 121.741   101 San Francisco Giants New York NL LF 94.780
   22 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SP 121.436   102 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SP 94.619
   23 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CL 120.956   103 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CL 94.291
   24 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SS 120.359   104 Atlanta Braves Boston NL C 94.027
 T25  Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SS 119.815   105 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SP 93.923
 T25  New York Yankees New York AL SS 119.815   106 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 2B 93.543
   27 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 3B 119.440   107 Atlanta Braves Boston NL RF 92.403
   28 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CF 119.335   108 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SP 92.120
   29 San Francisco Giants New York NL 1B 118.438   109 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 1B 92.089
   30 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL C 118.349   110 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CF 91.672
   31 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SP 117.990   111 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SS 91.515
   32 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 3B 117.817   112 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL C 91.204
   33 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CL 117.702   113 New York Yankees New York AL RF 90.970
   34 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SS 116.281   114 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CF 90.751
   35 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 1B 116.010   115 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 1B 90.514
   36 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CF 115.326   116 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL C 90.319
   37 San Francisco Giants New York NL CF 115.205   117 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 1B 90.216
   38 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL LF 114.957   118 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 2B 90.092
   39 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SP 113.489   119 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SS 89.983
   40 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL RF 113.298   120 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL RF 88.844
   41 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL LF 113.143   121 New York Yankees New York AL LF 88.408
   42 San Francisco Giants New York NL SS 112.851   122 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 2B 88.344
   43 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CF 112.673   123 New York Yankees New York AL SP 87.352
   44 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL RF 112.558   124 Minnesota Twins Washington AL LF 86.912
   45 San Francisco Giants New York NL 3B 112.242   125 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 3B 86.789
   46 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SS 112.146   126 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SS 86.073
   47 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL RF 111.130   127 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CF 85.846
   48 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SP 110.667   128 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CF 85.752
   49 San Francisco Giants New York NL SP 110.221   129 Minnesota Twins Washington AL C 85.366
   50 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL LF 109.880   130 Atlanta Braves Boston NL LF 85.305
   51 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 3B 109.726   131 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 2B 83.883
   52 San Francisco Giants New York NL RF 109.601   132 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 3B 83.794
   53 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 2B 109.410   133 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL C 83.588
   54 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 3B 109.360   134 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 1B 83.260
   55 New York Yankees New York AL 1B 109.066   135 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 2B 83.225
   56 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL LF 108.493   136 New York Yankees New York AL C 83.022
   57 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL RF 108.328   137 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 2B 82.305
   58 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL C 108.204   138 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SS 81.881
   59 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL C 107.956   139 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 1B 81.402
   60 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CF 106.806   140 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CL 81.339
   61 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SP 106.754   141 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 1B 81.034
   62 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL LF 106.517   142 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CF 80.650
   63 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SP 106.314   143 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CL 80.275
   64 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL C 105.185   144 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 3B 78.091
   65 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CF 105.045   145 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SS 77.300
   66 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 2B 104.700   146 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SS 76.757
   67 Boston Red Sox Boston AL C 104.445   147 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL LF 76.015
   68 New York Yankees New York AL 2B 104.219   148 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SS 75.972
   69 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 1B 104.166   149 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CF 68.414
   70 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 3B 104.121   150 New York Yankees New York AL CL 68.037
   71 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 1B 103.849   151 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 2B 67.236
   72 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SS 103.750   152 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL RF 66.744
   73 Boston Red Sox Boston AL RF 103.439   153 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 2B 66.603
   74 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CF 103.354   154 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SP 66.423
   75 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL RF 102.972   155 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CL 64.501
   76 New York Yankees New York AL 3B 102.822   156 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 3B 64.134
   77 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SP 102.510   157 Minnesota Twins Washington AL RF 63.668
   78 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL C 102.504   158 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CL 51.406
   79 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 2B 102.484   159 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CL 34.775
   80 San Francisco Giants New York NL 2B 102.225   160 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CL 33.594
Copyright © 2009-11 by Andre Lower
Sources:
All-Time Major League Handbook
Win Shares Digital Update
baseball-reference.com
ESPN Baseball Encyclopedia