You can show your support by sponsoring this page for $5. Home All-time Team Position Rating through 1907
  Your ad/message will appear in this space for one year.   Annual Index
  Thank you for your support!  
   
       
Cumulative Cumulative
Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate Rank Franchise City League Pos WS Rate
    1 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CL 203.063    81 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CL 100.964
    2 San Francisco Giants New York NL CL 195.250    82 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 1B 100.927
    3 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 2B 158.028    83 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL RF 100.341
    4 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 1B 151.093    84 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SP 100.149
    5 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CL 145.207    85 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SP 99.881
    6 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL RF 141.523    86 Boston Red Sox Boston AL RF 99.782
    7 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 3B 136.696    87 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL LF 99.749
    8 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 2B 135.076    88 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 3B 99.722
    9 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 1B 133.961    89 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL LF 99.557
   10 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CF 131.970    90 Boston Red Sox Boston AL LF 98.942
   11 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CL 131.962    91 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CL 98.922
   12 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 2B 131.139    92 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SP 98.867
   13 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL LF 130.385    93 Atlanta Braves Boston NL C 98.069
   14 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 3B 130.359    94 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 3B 97.851
   15 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL LF 130.312    95 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL LF 97.639
   16 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 3B 130.265    96 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SS 96.966
   17 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SS 130.232    97 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL C 96.921
   18 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CF 130.063    98 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL SP 96.690
   19 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL RF 128.585  T99  Atlanta Braves Boston NL 2B 96.665
   20 New York Yankees New York AL SS 126.826  T99  Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CF 96.665
   21 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL RF 126.606   101 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 3B 96.413
   22 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL CF 124.852   102 Atlanta Braves Boston NL RF 96.088
   23 San Francisco Giants New York NL C 123.270   103 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL 1B 96.069
   24 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL SS 123.070   104 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 2B 95.855
   25 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL RF 122.219   105 San Francisco Giants New York NL 2B 95.459
   26 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL RF 121.463   106 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL C 95.445
   27 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SS 121.361   107 Minnesota Twins Washington AL LF 95.329
   28 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SP 121.295   108 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CL 95.292
   29 San Francisco Giants New York NL 1B 120.425   109 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL RF 95.102
   30 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL C 119.422   110 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SS 94.598
   31 New York Yankees New York AL 2B 118.983   111 San Francisco Giants New York NL LF 94.255
   32 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SP 118.303   112 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL C 92.507
   33 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL LF 117.700   113 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL SS 92.478
   34 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 1B 117.249   114 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 1B 92.254
   35 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SP 117.230   115 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SP 92.027
   36 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL C 115.916   116 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 1B 91.409
   37 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SP 115.775   117 New York Yankees New York AL SP 90.821
   38 San Francisco Giants New York NL CF 115.582   118 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 2B 90.803
   39 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL CL 114.637   119 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL C 89.889
   40 Boston Red Sox Boston AL SS 114.597   120 New York Yankees New York AL CF 89.633
   41 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL SP 114.320   121 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 1B 88.038
   42 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CF 112.987   122 Minnesota Twins Washington AL C 87.531
   43 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL SP 112.952   123 New York Yankees New York AL RF 87.358
   44 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL SS 112.441   124 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL RF 87.138
   45 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL RF 112.205   125 Atlanta Braves Boston NL LF 87.029
   46 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL C 112.104   126 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 2B 86.724
   47 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL C 110.827   127 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL CF 86.582
   48 San Francisco Giants New York NL SS 110.725   128 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL CF 86.277
   49 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL 3B 110.534   129 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CF 86.187
   50 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL LF 110.334   130 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL C 86.174
   51 San Francisco Giants New York NL 3B 110.230   131 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL 1B 85.447
   52 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CF 110.078   132 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 1B 84.668
   53 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL LF 109.837   133 New York Yankees New York AL C 84.025
   54 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL 2B 109.728   134 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 3B 83.260
   55 Atlanta Braves Boston NL CL 109.666   135 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 2B 82.839
   56 Atlanta Braves Boston NL SS 109.416   136 New York Yankees New York AL LF 82.798
   57 Boston Red Sox Boston AL CF 109.162   137 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 3B 82.380
   58 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 3B 108.953   138 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 1B 81.892
   59 San Francisco Giants New York NL SP 107.911   139 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL SS 81.840
   60 New York Yankees New York AL 3B 107.908   140 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL SS 80.358
   61 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL 3B 106.369   141 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL 1B 80.211
   62 New York Yankees New York AL 1B 105.884   142 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SS 78.611
   63 San Francisco Giants New York NL RF 105.824   143 Philadelphia Phillies Philadelphia NL CL 77.063
   64 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL C 105.810   144 Boston Red Sox Boston AL 2B 74.837
   65 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 3B 105.580   145 Oakland Athletics Philadelphia AL SS 74.069
   66 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL C 104.763   146 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL LF 74.034
   67 Atlanta Braves Boston NL 1B 104.229   147 Minnesota Twins Washington AL 3B 73.599
   68 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL CF 104.173   148 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SS 72.235
   69 Boston Red Sox Boston AL C 103.589   149 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 2B 70.440
   70 Los Angeles Dodgers Brooklyn NL LF 103.517   150 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CL 70.023
   71 Cincinnati Reds Cincinnati NL 1B 102.923   151 Minnesota Twins Washington AL CF 64.307
   72 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL SP 102.791   152 Detroit Tigers Detroit AL 2B 63.932
   73 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL 2B 102.619   153 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL RF 63.620
   74 New York Yankees New York AL CL 102.099   154 Minnesota Twins Washington AL RF 60.375
   75 Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CF 101.991   155 Minnesota Twins Washington AL SP 60.312
   76 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL RF 101.970  T156  Cleveland Indians Cleveland AL CL 52.184
   77 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL SP 101.533  T156  Detroit Tigers Detroit AL CL 52.184
   78 Pittsburgh Pirates Pittsburgh NL CF 101.274   158 Baltimore Orioles St. Louis AL 3B 52.144
   79 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL LF 101.249   159 Chicago White Sox Chicago AL CL 48.780
   80 Chicago Cubs Chicago NL 2B 100.972   160 St. Louis Cardinals St. Louis NL CL 32.072
Copyright © 2009-11 by Andre Lower
Sources:
All-Time Major League Handbook
Win Shares Digital Update
baseball-reference.com
ESPN Baseball Encyclopedia